What does the new Supreme Court Justice and business have to do with each other?
With all of the hullabaloo surrounding the election of 2016, it’s easy to forget that there is a vacancy on the Supreme Court that will be filled by this president. Many will forget a president’s decisions over his or her term of office (or reversed by the next administration). But the ability to leave a lasting impression on the American justice system is an example of the power of the office of President of the United States.
The Presidential Decision
A president’s term is only 4-8 years, but the decisions he or she makes in those years are crucial for America’s future. Since Supreme Court justices serve for life, whoever is appointed will influence our legal system for decades.
- Marbury v. Madison (judicial review over Congress)
- McCulloch v. Maryland (federal power over states)
- Gideon v. Wainwright (right to attorney)
- Roe v. Wade (right to abortion)
- Obergefell v. Hodges (same-sex marriage)
(Before any nominations are made, it’s wise to analyze areas in your company that would be impacted by a Supreme Court decision. To do this, check out our free External Analysis whitepaper by clicking here.)
President-Elect Trump’s Potential Nominees
Justice Antonin Scalia’s untimely death in February 2016 created a vacancy on the US Supreme Court. President-Elect Donald Trump has compiled a list of potential replacements – with the majority having a conservative agenda. Additionally, the two liberal-leaning justices are also approaching retirement. With 1 vacancy and 2 potential vacancies in Trump’s tenure as President, he will potentially have 3 positions to fill.
According to Business Insider, Trump’s potential nominees are as follows: (links are attached for biographies)
- Keith Blackwell
- Charles Canady
- Steven Colloton
- Allison Eid
- Neil Gorsuch
- Raymond Gruender
- Thomas Hardiman
- Raymond Kethledge
- Joan Larsen
- Mike Lee
- Thomas Lee
- Edward Mansfield
- Federico Moreno
- William Pryor
- Margaret A. Ryan
- Amul Thapar
- Timothy Tymkovich
- David Stras
- Diane Sykes
- Don Willett
- Robert Young
So why does this affect your business?
As we discussed earlier, decisions made by the judges have the ability to change the course of the economy, justice system, and social system. With the new justices, however, decisions that have already been decided on may be reviewed again.
Example: Affordable Care Act & Gay Marriage
The Supreme Court has already ruled on the Affordable Care Act and the legalization of gay marriage during President Barack Obama’s tenure. While these may seem like social issues – right to basic health care and right to gay marriage – there are huge implications for businesses as well.
Who gets benefits?
But with the legalization of gay marriage, more people are open to healthcare. Although this is great for the people affected, companies will foot the bill. After talking to multiple small businesses (1-10 employees) across Texas, I’ve seen companies go out of business due to Obamacare and others that are now spending over $12,000 more than what they were previously spending.
Companies must provide benefits to all marriages (401k, health, parental leave, etc.). This leaves companies paying more than before for benefits. While this is great news to these employees, it’s a great example of just how Supreme Court decisions impact the bottom line of companies.
Due to the extreme discontent among businesses nationwide, the Affordable Care Act will be amended and potentially reviewed again by the Supreme Court with a different justices. With a new set of justices (with a potentially different ideology), decisions could be overturned.
How Supreme Court Decisions Impact Businesses
Before we go into how Supreme Court decisions impact business, we must go over how cases get to the Supreme Court. Cases reach the Supreme Court in 1 of 3 ways – including original jurisdiction (dealing with mostly foreign affairs and diplomats), state Supreme Courts, and Federal Courts. A case progresses from the lower courts upward. Then if granted appeal enough times, a case can reach the Supreme Court. The lower court’s previous ruling stands if there is not a majority decision.
The Supreme Court also has checks and balances on the other branches of government. Their main priority is to uphold and interpret the Constitution; therefore the 9 (8 current) Supreme Court justices will try anything debated as unconstitutional in Congress or the executive office.
What Areas You Should Watch For
Fortune Magazine outlined several areas to watch for, especially after Scalia’s death. The Supreme Court could impact these following 5 areas in the new year are:
- Class action suits
- Pollution regulations
- Intellectual property.
For example, United States v. Texas deals with immigration and DAPA (Deferred Action for Parents of Americans). As one of the states that did not join the original suit, Texas faces the decision that 2.2 million illegal aliens residing in Texas (out of the 3.6 million total illegal aliens) are eligible for DAPA. This potential decision will then increase competition for jobs, increase benefits and taxes for those added employees, and increase unemployment rates due to the millions being added to the limited job pool.
Whatever industry you are in, it’s important to know what type of decisions will greatly impact your company. Conduct an external analysis to start your path towards capitalizing on strengths and opportunities alongside minimizing the negative impact of weaknesses and threats. Get your free copy of our External Analysis whitepaper here.
Access your Strategic Pricing Model Execution Plan in SCFO Lab. The step-by-step plan to set your prices to maximize profits.
Click here to access your Execution Plan. Not a Lab Member?
Click here to learn more about SCFO Labs